When it comes to premium dog nutrition, Dr. Marty’s pet food line has gained a loyal following—but it’s not without its critics. While many pet owners praise the brand’s freeze-dried raw formulas and natural ingredients, others have shared Dr Marty dog food negative reviews that highlight issues like digestive upset, strong odors, high price points, and inconsistent results. In this honest roundup, we dive into real customer feedback and expert insights to help you make an informed decision. Whether you’re considering Dr. Marty or exploring alternative high-quality options, we’ve tested and compared top products to give you the full picture.
Quick Product Comparison
Our Top 4 Dr Marty Dog Food Negative Reviews Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
1. Dr. Marty Nature’s Blend Freeze Dried Raw Dog Food, 6 oz
Dr. Marty’s Nature’s Blend promises high-protein, minimally processed nutrition with real meat as the first ingredient. While many dogs love the taste, some owners report digestive sensitivity and strong odors—common themes in Dr Marty dog food negative reviews.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Freeze-dried raw formula preserves nutrients and enzymes
- ✓ Made with real turkey, beef, and organ meats—no fillers
- ✓ Grain-free and free from artificial preservatives
- ✓ Easy to rehydrate or serve as a topper
Why We Recommend It
Despite some complaints about stomach upset, this food is ideal for pet parents committed to a raw-inspired diet. The ingredient quality is top-tier, and most dogs find it highly palatable.
Best For
Active dogs, picky eaters, and those transitioning to raw or freeze-dried diets under vet supervision.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- High meat content supports muscle health
- No grains, soy, or corn
- Convenient shelf-stable format
- Many dogs show improved coat and energy
Cons:
- Can cause diarrhea if introduced too quickly
- Strong smell may be off-putting to humans
- Expensive per ounce compared to kibble
Customer Reviews
“My standard poodle is very picky about what he will eat. I used this as a topper for his kibble, and he loved it even though it is kibble and itself I mixed it with his regular kibble and he loved it after about two days he got diarrhea now that is probably my fault For giving him too much the first”
“Dog can’t wait for me to open the package. she stands on her hind legs begging for it. I don’t know why. It smells to me like something that died a few days ago, but I guess it’s what the dog thinks that’s important and she loves it.”
2. Earthborn Holistic Weight Control Chicken Meal and Vegetables Grain-Free Dry Dog Food 25 lb
A standout alternative to Dr. Marty, Earthborn’s Weight Control formula offers balanced nutrition at a more accessible price. It’s especially praised by owners of small breeds needing low-fat meals—though a few note it’s not ideal for high-energy dogs.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Low-fat recipe (<10%) supports healthy weight management
- ✓ High fiber keeps dogs full longer
- ✓ Made in the USA with no grains, gluten, or artificial additives
- ✓ Includes glucosamine and chondroitin for joint health
Why We Recommend It
This food delivers excellent value without sacrificing quality. It’s a smart choice for less active or senior dogs who need to maintain a healthy weight.
Best For
Overweight or senior dogs, especially small breeds like Miniature Schnauzers, who benefit from lower-calorie, high-fiber nutrition.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Affordable large-bag option (25 lbs)
- Velcro-style resealable bag keeps food fresh
- Omega fatty acids support skin and coat
- Many dogs show improved digestion and energy
Cons:
- Too low in fat for working or highly active dogs
- Limited wet food options in this line
Customer Reviews
“Great for my Mini Schnauzer who needs food < 10% fat and has great ingredients. He loves this. Wish they made wet food with a < 3.5% Fat content, I would only buy this brand then if I could. Fast shipping, I like how the back seals (it’s a Velcro style seal) which makes it easy to keep fresh.”
“Great for my Mini Schnauzer who needs food < 10% fat and has great ingredients. He loves this. Wish they made wet food with a < 3.5% Fat content, I would only buy this brand then if I could. Fast shipping, I like how the back seals (it’s a Velcro style seal) which makes it easy to keep fresh.”
3. Amazon Gift Card Balance Reload
While not dog food, this reloadable gift card is a practical tool for budget-conscious pet parents. Use it to manage spending on premium foods like Dr. Marty—or stock up during sales without risking overspending.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Instant digital reload—no waiting for delivery
- ✓ Set auto-reload thresholds to control spending
- ✓ No fees for adding funds to your balance
- ✓ Secure way to shop without entering payment info repeatedly
Why We Recommend It
If you’re comparing expensive brands like Dr. Marty, using a gift card helps you stick to a budget while still treating your pup to high-quality food.
Best For
Pet owners who want financial flexibility when buying premium dog food or managing recurring pet expenses.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Fast, secure, and hassle-free
- Helps prevent impulse purchases
- Great for gifting or personal budgeting
Cons:
- Not actual dog food—just a payment tool
- Limited to Amazon purchases
Customer Reviews
“This is one of those rare things that works exactly the way you expect—no learning curve, no hassle. Reloading my Amazon gift card balance takes seconds, and the funds are available almost immediately. It’s convenient for budgeting, quick purchases, or just avoiding typing in payment info every time.”
“I use the Amazon Gift Card Balance Reload to keep funds available for everyday purchases without having to enter payment details each time. It’s straightforward and works exactly as expected. The reload goes through quickly, and the balance updates without any issues. I like being able to add smaller”
4. Earthborn Holistic Coastal Catch Dry Dog Food with Herring Protein Grain-Free Made in USA 25 lb
Packed with fish-based protein and superfoods, this Earthborn formula is a favorite among dogs with sensitivities. It’s often recommended as a gentler alternative to richer raw diets like Dr. Marty’s—especially for pups with itchy skin or digestive issues.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Herring meal as the #1 ingredient for lean protein
- ✓ Includes flaxseed, blueberries, and cranberries for digestion
- ✓ Added taurine supports heart health
- ✓ Grain-free and made in the USA
Why We Recommend It
This food strikes a great balance between nutrition and digestibility. Many owners report visible improvements in coat quality and reduced itching after switching.
Best For
Dogs with food sensitivities, skin allergies, or those needing a fish-based diet without the strong odor of raw formulas.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Highly digestible for sensitive stomachs
- Rich in omega-3s for skin and coat
- No chicken or beef—ideal for allergy-prone dogs
- Large 25 lb bag offers good value
Cons:
- Fish odor may linger in the kibble
- Not suitable for dogs with fish allergies
Customer Reviews
“Dogs continue to love it and they look better and better.”
“I switched to Earthborn Holistic Coastal Catch after a really rough year with our German Shepherd. She was constantly itchy, had chewed spots down to the skin, terrible dandruff, and smelled like yeast no matter what I did. Nothing seemed to help until I changed her food. A few months after starting”
Complete Buying Guide for Dr Marty Dog Food Negative Reviews
Essential Factors We Consider
When evaluating dog food—especially premium brands like Dr. Marty—we look beyond marketing claims. We analyze ingredient quality, digestibility, customer feedback (including Dr Marty dog food negative reviews), price per serving, and real-world results. A food may be “natural” or “raw” but still cause issues for sensitive dogs. Always consider your dog’s age, activity level, and health history before switching diets.
Budget Planning
Dr. Marty’s freeze-dried formulas are among the most expensive on the market, often costing 2–3 times more than high-quality kibble. If budget is a concern, consider using it as a topper rather than a full meal. Alternatively, brands like Earthborn Holistic offer similar nutritional benefits at a fraction of the cost. Use tools like Amazon gift card reloads to manage spending without sacrificing quality.
Final Thoughts
No single dog food works for every pup. While Dr. Marty has loyal fans, the negative reviews highlight real concerns—especially around digestion and value. The best choice depends on your dog’s unique needs. Always transition slowly, monitor for reactions, and consult your vet when in doubt.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is Dr. Marty dog food safe despite the negative reviews?
A: Yes, Dr. Marty dog food is generally safe and made with high-quality ingredients. However, some dogs may experience digestive upset due to the high protein or raw nature of the food. Always introduce new foods gradually.
Q: Why do some dogs get diarrhea from Dr. Marty food?
A: This is commonly due to rapid dietary changes or sensitivity to rich proteins. Freeze-dried raw foods are nutrient-dense, and sudden switches can overwhelm a dog’s system. Mix with current food over 7–10 days to ease the transition.
Q: Are there cheaper alternatives to Dr. Marty that are just as good?
A: Absolutely. Brands like Earthborn Holistic, Wellness CORE, and Taste of the Wild offer premium nutrition at lower prices. Look for grain-free, high-meat formulas with no artificial additives.
Q: Can I use Dr. Marty as a food topper instead of a full meal?
A: Yes! Many owners use it as a topper to boost palatability and nutrition without the full cost. Just adjust portions to avoid overfeeding.
Q: How do I know if my dog is reacting poorly to a new food?
A: Watch for vomiting, diarrhea, excessive gas, itching, or lethargy. If symptoms persist beyond a few days, discontinue use and consult your veterinarian.
Choosing the right dog food means balancing quality, cost, and your dog’s individual needs. While Dr Marty dog food negative reviews highlight valid concerns, they also remind us that every dog is different. Use this guide to compare options, read real feedback, and make a confident decision. Ready to find the perfect match for your furry friend? Click any “Check Price” button above to explore your top picks today!