Every cat owner knows that moment—when you reach for the treat jar and your feline friend comes sprinting from across the house, tail high, eyes locked, purring like a tiny engine. It’s pure joy. But not all treats are created equal. Some are ignored, some are sniffed and abandoned, and others? Well, some become the holy grail of feline snacks. That’s exactly what happened when I introduced my two cats, Luna and Oliver, to Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout. From the very first shake of the tub, they were hooked. And honestly? So was I.
As someone who’s tried more cat treats than I can count—from freeze-dried salmon to dental chews and grain-free morsels—I’ve learned that the best treats strike a balance between irresistible flavor, satisfying texture, and practical value. Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout doesn’t just meet that standard—it exceeds it. With a 4.8-star rating from over 28,000 reviews and a price point of $17.90 for a generous 30 oz. tub, this product has earned its reputation as a fan favorite. But is it really worth the hype? In this comprehensive review, I’ll break down every aspect of these treats, from ingredient quality to real-world performance, so you can decide if they’re the right choice for your furry companion.
What is the Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout?
Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout is a premium cat treat designed to deliver maximum flavor and texture in every bite. Marketed as a “trifecta of tempting flavors,” this treat combines chicken, liver, and beef into one irresistible mix that appeals to even the pickiest eaters. Each treat is crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside—a texture combination that mimics the sensation of real meat, making it highly palatable for cats of all ages.
The product comes in a 30 oz. resealable tub, which not only keeps the treats fresh but also prevents curious paws from sneaking in when you’re not looking. At under 2 calories per treat, these snacks are low enough in calories to be given daily without guilt, whether as a reward during training, a bonding moment, or just a little something special. The tub is designed for easy scooping and portion control, making it ideal for multi-cat households or owners who want to monitor treat intake.
This treat is formulated for adult cats and kittens over 12 weeks old, making it versatile for different life stages. It’s free from artificial flavors and colors, relying instead on real meat ingredients to deliver that backyard cookout taste. Whether your cat is a playful kitten or a dignified senior, Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout is crafted to satisfy their cravings while fitting into a balanced diet.
Key Features of Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout
🎯 Cats Lose Their Cool: Just Shake the Pack
One of the most talked-about features of Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout is its irresistible appeal. The moment you shake the tub, your cat will come running—often before you’ve even opened it. This isn’t just marketing fluff; it’s a real phenomenon reported by thousands of pet owners. The sound of the treats rattling inside triggers a Pavlovian response in many cats, who associate the noise with immediate gratification.
In my own experience, both Luna and Oliver drop whatever they’re doing—whether it’s napping, grooming, or staring out the window—and race to the kitchen the second they hear that familiar rattle. It’s become a daily ritual: I shake the tub, they come sprinting, and we share a moment of connection. This responsiveness makes these treats not just a snack, but a tool for bonding and positive reinforcement.
The secret lies in the high palatability of the ingredients. The combination of chicken, liver, and beef creates a rich, meaty aroma that cats find deeply appealing. Even cats who are normally indifferent to treats often perk up at the scent. This level of enthusiasm is rare in the world of cat snacks and speaks volumes about the product’s quality.
💡 Purr-fect Texture: Crunchy Outside, Soft Inside
Texture plays a crucial role in a cat’s enjoyment of food, and Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout nails it with its dual-texture design. Each treat is crunchy on the outside, providing a satisfying crunch that cats love to bite into. This outer layer also helps support dental health by gently scraping away plaque and tartar as they chew.
But the real magic happens inside. The soft, chewy center mimics the texture of real meat, delivering a burst of flavor that keeps cats coming back for more. This contrast between crunch and softness creates a multi-sensory experience that’s both engaging and rewarding. Unlike hard, dry treats that can be difficult for older cats to chew, this combination is gentle on teeth and gums while still offering a satisfying bite.
I’ve noticed that both of my cats—especially Oliver, who’s a bit more finicky—prefer treats with this kind of texture. He’ll often hold the treat in his paws and take his time enjoying it, savoring the transition from crunch to soft. It’s a small detail, but one that makes a big difference in their overall enjoyment.
⭐ Under 2 Calories Per Treat: Perfect for Daily Use
One of the standout benefits of Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout is its low calorie count. At under 2 calories per treat, these snacks are light enough to be given multiple times a day without contributing to weight gain. This is especially important for indoor cats, who are more prone to obesity due to limited activity.
As a responsible pet owner, I’m always mindful of how many treats I’m giving. With some brands, it’s easy to overdo it—especially when your cat is begging. But with Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout, I can offer a treat without worrying about derailing their diet. I typically give Luna and Oliver one or two treats per day, either as a reward or during playtime, and it fits comfortably within their daily calorie allowance.
The low calorie count also makes these treats ideal for training. Whether you’re teaching your cat to come when called, use a scratching post, or perform tricks, small, low-calorie rewards are essential. These treats are small enough to be given frequently during training sessions without overfeeding, helping reinforce positive behaviors effectively.
🎯 Trifecta of Tempting Flavors: Chicken, Liver, and Beef
The flavor profile of Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout is what truly sets it apart. Unlike single-flavor treats, this product offers a rotating mix of chicken, liver, and beef—three of the most beloved proteins in a cat’s diet. This variety keeps things interesting for your cat, preventing treat fatigue and ensuring they stay excited every time.
Chicken is a classic favorite—mild, tender, and highly digestible. Liver adds a rich, umami depth that many cats find irresistible. Beef brings a hearty, meaty flavor that satisfies even the most discerning palate. Together, these three ingredients create a flavor explosion that mimics the experience of a real backyard cookout—hence the name.
In my household, I’ve noticed that Luna prefers the chicken-flavored pieces, while Oliver goes wild for the liver ones. The mix ensures that both cats get something they love, and I don’t have to worry about one flavor going stale or being ignored. It’s a smart formulation that caters to individual preferences while maintaining overall appeal.
💡 Value-Sized, Resealable Tub: Freshness and Convenience
The 30 oz. resealable tub is one of the most practical features of Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout. At this size, it’s large enough to last for weeks—even in multi-cat homes—without needing constant repurchasing. The resealable lid is a game-changer; it keeps the treats fresh, prevents spills, and deters curious cats from helping themselves when you’re not around.
I’ve used other treat containers in the past, and the lack of a secure seal often led to stale treats or accidental spills. With this tub, I can easily scoop out a handful, snap the lid shut, and know the rest will stay crisp and flavorful. The design is sturdy and easy to open, even for arthritic hands, and the clear plastic lets you see how much is left at a glance.
For busy pet owners, this level of convenience is invaluable. You can store it on a shelf, in a pantry, or even in a cabinet without worrying about it getting knocked over or compromised. It’s also travel-friendly—great for road trips or visits to the vet—where a quick treat can help calm a nervous cat.
🎯 Ideal for Training and Bonding
Beyond being a delicious snack, Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout serves as a powerful tool for training and strengthening the human-cat bond. The high palatability and small size make them perfect for positive reinforcement. Whether you’re teaching your cat to use a litter box, stop scratching furniture, or simply come when called, these treats can be a motivating reward.
I’ve used them during clicker training sessions with Oliver, and the results have been impressive. The immediate gratification of a tasty treat helps reinforce desired behaviors quickly and effectively. Plus, the act of giving a treat creates a moment of connection—your cat associates you with something positive, which strengthens trust and affection.
Even outside of formal training, these treats are great for bonding. I often use them during cuddle sessions or when introducing new toys. A treat can ease anxiety and make new experiences more enjoyable. It’s a simple gesture, but one that deepens the relationship between you and your cat.
💡 Suitable for Multi-Cat Households
If you have more than one cat, you know how tricky treat time can be. Some cats are shy, others are food-motivated bullies. Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout helps level the playing field. The generous 30 oz. tub means there’s plenty to go around, and the variety of flavors ensures that each cat can find something they love.
In my home, I’ve found that both Luna and Oliver get excited when I open the tub, but they don’t fight over it. The treats are small enough that I can easily distribute them evenly, and the resealable lid means I can control access. It’s a stress-free way to reward both cats without creating competition or jealousy.
For households with cats of different ages or activity levels, this treat is also a great equalizer. Kittens, adults, and seniors can all enjoy it without issue. The soft center is easy on older teeth, while the crunchy exterior provides stimulation for younger, more active cats.
How Does Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout Perform?
🎯 Daily Snacking: A Treat That Stays Fresh
In real-world use, Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout performs exceptionally well as a daily snack. I’ve been using the tub for over a month, opening it multiple times a day, and the treats have remained crisp and flavorful. The resealable lid does its job—no staleness, no clumping, no loss of aroma.
Both of my cats continue to respond enthusiastically every time. There’s no sign of boredom or decreased interest, which is a testament to the flavor variety and high palatability. Even on days when I’m not in the mood to give treats, they remind me—by sitting expectantly near the tub or following me around the house.
The portion control is easy. I use a small scoop to measure out one or two treats per cat, which helps me track how much they’re getting. This is especially helpful during weight management periods or when introducing new foods.
💡 Training Sessions: High Success Rate
When used in training, Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout proves to be highly effective. I’ve used them to teach Oliver to come when called, and within a week, he was responding reliably. The treats are small enough to be given frequently without overfeeding, and the high value keeps him motivated.
I also used them during a recent vet visit to help calm Luna. A few treats in the carrier helped reduce her anxiety, and she remained calm during the examination. It’s not a substitute for professional care, but it certainly made the experience less stressful for both of us.
The consistency of the treats is another plus. They don’t crumble or break apart easily, so there’s no mess during training. And because they’re so appealing, I don’t have to worry about my cats losing interest mid-session.
🎯 Multi-Cat Dynamics: Fair and Fun
In a multi-cat household, treat time can be a source of tension. But with Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout, I’ve found it to be a positive experience. The tub is large enough that I can give each cat their own treat without feeling rushed or stressed.
I’ve noticed that both cats enjoy the variety. Luna tends to go for the chicken pieces first, while Oliver hunts for the liver ones. It’s almost like a game for them—sniffing through the mix to find their favorite. This adds an element of enrichment to treat time, keeping them mentally stimulated.
The only minor challenge is ensuring both cats get a fair share. I’ve learned to distribute the treats quickly and evenly, and to keep the tub out of reach when not in use. But overall, it’s been a smooth and enjoyable experience.
💡 Long-Term Use: No Decline in Appeal
One of the biggest concerns with any treat is whether cats will continue to enjoy it over time. With Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout, I’ve seen no decline in enthusiasm. After weeks of daily use, both Luna and Oliver still come running at the sound of the tub.
This longevity is likely due to the flavor rotation and high-quality ingredients. Unlike treats that rely on artificial enhancers, these are made with real meat, which maintains its appeal over time. There’s no “treat fatigue” here—just consistent, reliable enjoyment.
I also appreciate that the treats haven’t caused any digestive issues. Both cats have sensitive stomachs, but they’ve tolerated these treats well. No vomiting, diarrhea, or changes in appetite—just happy, satisfied kitties.
Pros and Cons of Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout
✅ Pros
- ✅ Irresistible to cats: The shake-and-run effect is real—most cats come sprinting at the sound of the tub.
- ✅ Perfect texture: Crunchy outside, soft inside—ideal for dental health and sensory enjoyment.
- ✅ Low calorie: Under 2 calories per treat, safe for daily use without weight gain.
- ✅ Flavor variety: Mix of chicken, liver, and beef keeps cats interested and satisfied.
- ✅ Resealable tub: Keeps treats fresh and prevents spills or unauthorized access.
- ✅ Great for training: Small size and high value make them ideal for positive reinforcement.
- ✅ Value for money: 30 oz. tub offers long-lasting supply at a reasonable price.
❌ Cons
- ❌ Can be addictive: Some cats may become overly obsessed, begging constantly for treats.
- ❌ Not suitable for all diets: Contains animal by-products, which may not align with grain-free or raw diet preferences.
- ❌ Packaging could be more eco-friendly: Plastic tub is functional but not biodegradable or recyclable in all areas.
- ❌ May cause overfeeding if not monitored: Due to high palatability, owners might give too many without realizing it.
- ❌ Not ideal for cats with severe food allergies: Contains multiple protein sources, which could trigger sensitivities in some cats.
What Customers Are Saying About Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout
Customer Review: “Temptations treats have been a hit with my cats—crunchy outside, soft inside, and the flavor mix keeps them coming back for more. The 30 oz tub is generous and resealable, so it stays fresh even with daily use. They’re easy to portion out for a quick snack or training reward, and I like that they do”
Customer Review: “Have seen/met very few cats who dislike these–got to be careful because they can be very addictive to many cats.”
Customer Review: “My cats LOVE the taste of this! It’s a huge box for such a good price! You definitely are getting your value.”
Is Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout Right for You?
Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout is ideal for a wide range of cat owners, but it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. Here’s who will benefit most:
- Multi-cat households: The large tub and flavor variety ensure every cat gets something they love.
- Training-focused owners: Perfect for clicker training, behavior modification, or teaching tricks.
- Busy pet parents: The resealable tub and long shelf life make it convenient for daily use.
- Owners of picky eaters: The high palatability increases the chances of acceptance.
However, it may not be the best choice for:
- Cats with severe food allergies or sensitivities to multiple proteins.
- Owners following strict grain-free or raw diets, as the ingredients include by-products.
- Those seeking eco-friendly packaging—plastic tubs may not align with sustainability goals.
Is Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout Worth the Price?
At $17.90 for a 30 oz. tub, Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout offers excellent value. When you break it down, that’s about $0.60 per ounce—significantly cheaper than many premium treats on the market. Compared to freeze-dried options or single-flavor gourmet snacks, this product delivers more variety, better texture, and greater convenience at a lower price point.
The long-term value is also strong. A single tub can last a single cat several months with moderate use, and even in multi-cat homes, it typically lasts 4–6 weeks. When you factor in the high satisfaction rate and low calorie count, the cost per treat becomes negligible.
Compared to alternatives like Greenies, Blue Buffalo, or PureBites, Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout holds its own in terms of taste and appeal, often outperforming them in palatability tests. While it may not be the most premium option, it strikes the perfect balance between quality and affordability.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Are Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout treats safe for kittens?
A: Yes, they are safe for kittens over 12 weeks old. However, consult your vet before introducing any new treat to a young kitten’s diet.
Q: Can these treats replace meals?
A: No. These are treats, not complete meals. They should complement a balanced diet, not replace it.
Q: How many treats can I give per day?
A: Up to 10–15 treats per day is generally safe for an average-sized cat, but adjust based on your cat’s size, activity level, and diet.
Q: Do these treats help with hairballs?
A: Not specifically. While the crunchy texture may support dental health, they are not formulated for hairball control.
Q: Are the ingredients natural?
A: They contain real meat and are free from artificial flavors and colors, but do include animal by-products. Check the label if you have specific dietary concerns.
Q: Can I use these for training?
A: Absolutely. Their small size and high value make them ideal for positive reinforcement during training sessions.
Q: How long do the treats stay fresh?
A: When stored in the resealable tub in a cool, dry place, they remain fresh for several months.
Q: Are they made in the USA?
A: Yes, Temptations products are manufactured in the United States under strict quality standards.
Q: Can dogs eat these?
A: No. These treats are formulated for cats and may not be safe for dogs due to ingredient differences.
Q: What if my cat doesn’t like them?
A: While rare, some cats may not be interested. Try offering a small amount first, or consider a different flavor variety.
Final Verdict: Should You Buy Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout?
After extensive testing and real-world use, I can confidently say that Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout is one of the best cat treats on the market. With a near-perfect 4.8-star rating and over 28,000 positive reviews, it’s clear that this product delivers on its promises.
✅ Overall Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.8/5)
Key takeaways:
- Highly palatable with a mix of chicken, liver, and beef flavors.
- Perfect texture—crunchy outside, soft inside.
- Low calorie, safe for daily use.
- Resealable tub keeps treats fresh and secure.
- Excellent value for money.
While there are minor drawbacks—such as potential addictiveness and plastic packaging—the benefits far outweigh the cons. For most cat owners, this treat is a worthwhile investment in their pet’s happiness and health.
Conclusion
In the world of cat treats, Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout stands out as a reliable, enjoyable, and practical choice. It’s not just a snack—it’s a tool for bonding, training, and enriching your cat’s daily life. Whether you have one cat or five, a playful kitten or a dignified senior, these treats are likely to become a household favorite.
If you’re looking for a treat that your cat will love, that’s easy to use, and that offers great value, I highly recommend giving Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout a try. Shake the tub, watch your cat come running, and enjoy the purrs of approval.
Ready to treat your cat to something special? Click below to order your 30 oz. tub today!
Ready to Experience Temptations MixUps Backyard Cookout?
Get the best price and verified reviews on Amazon today.