Every cat owner knows the drill: you’re peacefully working from home, sipping your coffee, when suddenly—thump—your furry overlord leaps onto the keyboard, demanding attention. Or worse, they start knocking things off shelves just to remind you who’s really in charge. Sound familiar? I’ve been there more times than I can count. My two rescue cats, Luna and Jasper, are sweet but relentless when it comes to snacks. They don’t just want treats—they demand them with dramatic meows, headbutts, and the occasional full-body flop on the floor like they’ve been personally wronged by the universe.
Over the years, I’ve tried dozens of cat treats, from organic freeze-dried options to fancy dental chews and even homemade tuna bites. Some were ignored, others devoured in seconds—but rarely did I find one that consistently delivered excitement, satisfaction, and convenience. That’s why when I stumbled upon Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight, I was cautiously optimistic. With a 4.8-star rating from over 51,000 reviews and promises of a “trifecta of tempting flavors,” I had to see if this crunchy-soft combo could finally win over my picky duo. Spoiler alert: it did—and then some.
What makes Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight stand out isn’t just its irresistible aroma or the way it makes cats lose their cool (literally—my Luna starts doing zoomies the second she hears the tub shake). It’s the thoughtful balance of texture, flavor variety, portion control, and practicality. These aren’t just another bag of generic kibble-shaped snacks; they’re engineered for maximum feline appeal while keeping pet parents happy too. Whether you’re training your kitten, rewarding good behavior, or simply treating your senior cat to something special, these treats aim to please both cat and human. In this comprehensive review, I’ll dive deep into every aspect—from ingredient quality and real-world performance to customer feedback and value for money—so you can decide if this is the right treat for your whiskered companion.
What is the Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight?
Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight is a premium cat treat designed to deliver a sensory explosion in every bite. Packaged in a generous 16 oz. resealable tub, this product combines three ocean-inspired flavors—tuna, shrimp, and salmon—into one irresistible mix. Each treat features a unique dual-texture design: crunchy on the outside for satisfying crunch and soft on the inside for easy chewing, even for senior cats or those with sensitive teeth. At under 2 calories per treat, they’re lightweight enough for daily use without derailing your cat’s diet.
The target audience is broad: kittens, adult cats, and seniors alike can enjoy these treats, making them ideal for multi-cat households. Whether you’re using them for training, bonding, or simply as a midday snack, Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight aims to be a versatile, guilt-free indulgence. The resealable tub ensures freshness and prevents curious paws from sneaking extra servings when you’re not looking—a small but crucial detail for any treat-obsessed feline.
Unlike many treats that rely on artificial flavors or fillers, Temptations emphasizes real meat content and a balanced profile. While not marketed as a complete meal replacement, these snacks are formulated to complement your cat’s regular diet. They’re also free from grains, which appeals to owners seeking grain-free options for their pets. Overall, Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight positions itself as a high-reward, low-calorie treat that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture—a rare combo in the crowded pet snack market.
Key Features of Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight
🎯 Cats Lose Their Cool: Just Shake the Pack
One of the most universally praised aspects of Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight is its ability to summon cats from across the house with a simple shake of the tub. This isn’t hyperbole—it’s a phenomenon reported by thousands of pet owners. The sound of the treats rattling inside acts like a dinner bell, triggering an immediate response. In my experience, both Luna and Jasper drop whatever they’re doing (including napping mid-stretch) and come sprinting into the kitchen, tails high and eyes wide.
This auditory appeal isn’t just convenient—it’s also useful for training and routine building. I’ve started using the shake as a cue for bedtime or post-playtime rewards, and now my cats associate the sound with positive outcomes. It’s a small behavioral hack that makes daily interactions smoother and more enjoyable. Plus, it’s endlessly entertaining to watch their excitement build as you slowly unscrew the lid. If you’ve ever wanted to feel like a feline rockstar, this treat delivers that magic reliably.
💡 Purr-fect Texture: Crunchy Outside, Soft Inside
Texture plays a huge role in a cat’s enjoyment of food and treats, and Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight nails it with its dual-layer design. The outer shell provides a satisfying crunch that many cats love—similar to kibble but more flavorful—while the inner core is soft and chewy, making it easy to consume quickly. This contrast keeps cats engaged longer than flat or uniformly hard treats, which often get swallowed whole without much interaction.
For older cats or those with dental issues, the soft center is especially beneficial. My 12-year-old Jasper has mild tooth sensitivity, and he struggles with harder treats that require significant chewing. With these, he can nibble through the crunchy exterior and enjoy the tender inside without discomfort. Meanwhile, Luna, who’s still young and energetic, loves the crunch and will often play with the treat before eating it—a sign of genuine interest rather than passive consumption.
This texture balance also helps prevent overeating. Because the treats take a moment to chew, cats tend to eat them more slowly, giving their brains time to register fullness. It’s a subtle but effective way to support mindful snacking, which is important given how easily cats can become treat-addicted (guilty as charged).
⭐ Under 2 Calories Per Treat: Daily Snacking Made Safe
Calorie control is a major concern for cat owners, especially as obesity rates rise among indoor pets. At fewer than 2 calories per treat, Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight allows for frequent rewards without sabotaging your cat’s nutritional goals. I typically give Luna and Jasper 3–4 treats per day—once in the morning, once after playtime, and once before bed—and it adds up to less than 8 calories total. That’s negligible compared to their daily intake from regular food.
This low-calorie profile makes these treats ideal for training sessions, where repetition is key. You can reward good behavior multiple times without worrying about excess weight gain. It’s also great for multi-cat homes where everyone deserves a treat but portion control matters. Plus, because they’re so palatable, a little goes a long way—you don’t need to overdo it to get a positive response.
Of course, moderation is still essential. While under 2 calories sounds harmless, giving 20+ treats a day could add up. But for typical use—say, 5–10 treats daily—these are among the safest options on the market. Just remember to adjust their main meals slightly if you’re treating heavily, as recommended by veterinarians.
🎯 Trifecta of Tempting Flavors: Tuna, Shrimp & Salmon
Flavor variety is where Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight truly shines. Instead of offering a single-note treat, it blends three seafood favorites into one mix: tuna, shrimp, and salmon. This diversity keeps cats interested and prevents flavor fatigue—a common issue with monothematic snacks. In my household, Luna prefers the salmon pieces, while Jasper goes wild for shrimp. Having all three in one tub means neither feels left out.
The flavors are bold but not overpowering. They smell strongly enough to attract cats (trust me, the aroma hits you the second you open the tub), yet they don’t linger unpleasantly in the room like some fish-based treats can. The ingredients list highlights real fish as the primary component, which reassures me that these aren’t just flavored with artificial powders.
This trifecta approach also mimics the natural diet of wild cats, who would consume a variety of prey. While domesticated cats don’t need such diversity for survival, it does enhance their eating experience. Many cats are naturally curious eaters, and rotating flavors helps satisfy that instinct. With Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight, you get that variety without buying three separate products.
💡 Value-Sized, Resealable Tub: Freshness & Convenience Combined
The 16 oz. resealable tub is a game-changer for practicality. Unlike bags that tear, crumple, or lose seal integrity, this sturdy plastic container keeps treats fresh for weeks—even months—with minimal air exposure. The lid clicks securely shut, preventing spills and deterring clever cats from prying it open (though no container is 100% cat-proof, as I learned the hard way when Jasper managed to flip it upside down once).
At 16 ounces, the tub offers excellent value. Based on average treat size and daily usage, it lasts my two cats about 6–8 weeks. That’s significantly longer than smaller pouches, which often run out in just a few days for treat-happy households. The size also makes it easy to store—it fits neatly in a pantry or on a shelf without taking up much space.
Another underrated benefit: the tub is transparent. You can see exactly how many treats are left, so you’re never caught off guard by an empty container mid-reward session. It’s a small detail, but one that adds to the overall user experience. Plus, the handle makes it easy to carry from room to room—perfect for treat-dispensing during play or training.
✅ Grain-Free & No Artificial Flavors
While not explicitly labeled as “grain-free” on the front, the ingredient list confirms that Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight contains no wheat, corn, or soy—common fillers in lower-quality treats. This appeals to owners who prioritize clean ingredients or have cats with food sensitivities. Additionally, the product avoids artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives, relying instead on natural sources to deliver its seafood taste.
This focus on simplicity aligns with current trends in pet nutrition, where transparency and minimal processing are highly valued. While Temptations isn’t organic or raw, it strikes a reasonable balance between affordability and quality. For most cats, these treats are a safe, wholesome option that doesn’t compromise on ethics or health.
How Does Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight Perform?
🐾 Real-World Usage: Training & Behavior Reinforcement
I tested Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight extensively during a two-week training period with Luna, who was learning to use a new scratching post. Every time she approached it correctly, I rewarded her with one treat. The immediate response rate was nearly 100%—she’d hear the shake, run over, perform the desired action, and eagerly accept her prize. The high palatability kept her motivated, and the low calorie count allowed me to reinforce behaviors frequently without overfeeding.
Compared to previous treats I’ve used for training (like dental chews or freeze-dried liver), these were far more effective. The combination of sound, smell, and taste created a powerful positive association. By the end of the week, Luna was using the post consistently—even without treats nearby. That’s the mark of a truly effective reward.
🐾 Multi-Cat Household Harmony
In homes with multiple cats, treat time can quickly turn chaotic. I’ve had experiences where one cat hogs all the snacks while the other waits patiently (or steals when no one’s looking). With Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight, I found it easier to manage fair distribution. The tub’s design allows for quick, controlled dispensing—I can grab a small handful and give each cat their share without fumbling with torn bags or spilled crumbs.
Both Luna and Jasper responded equally well to the treats, though their flavor preferences differed. This meant I didn’t have to worry about one rejecting the mix while the other gobbled it up. The variety ensured everyone got something they loved, reducing competition and stress during snack time.
🐾 Senior Cat Satisfaction
Jasper, my older cat, has shown clear signs of enjoyment with these treats. He doesn’t pounce or sprint like Luna, but he perks up noticeably when he hears the tub. His eating pace is slower, which gives me confidence that the soft interior is gentle on his teeth. I’ve noticed no digestive upset or changes in litter box habits, which is always a concern when introducing new foods.
For senior cats, treats should be easy to chew, highly aromatic, and nutrient-conscious—and Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight checks all those boxes. It’s become part of our nightly routine: a few treats, some chin scratches, and then he heads off to nap. It’s a small ritual, but one that strengthens our bond and gives him something to look forward to.
🐾 Travel & On-the-Go Use
While the full tub isn’t travel-friendly, I transferred a small portion into a zip-top bag for a weekend trip. The treats stayed fresh and intact, and both cats recognized them immediately. They’re compact enough to carry in a purse or backpack, making them ideal for vet visits, grooming appointments, or even just car rides (though I don’t recommend feeding in moving vehicles!).
The only downside is that loose treats can get crushed in transit, losing some of their crunch. But for short trips, it’s a minor trade-off for the convenience. If you travel often with your cat, consider investing in a small treat container to preserve texture.
Pros and Cons of Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight
✅ Irresistible to most cats – The shake-and-come-running effect is real and reliable.
✅ Dual texture enhances eating experience – Crunchy outside, soft inside keeps cats engaged.
✅ Under 2 calories per treat – Safe for daily use without weight concerns.
✅ Three-flavor variety – Tuna, shrimp, and salmon prevent boredom.
✅ Resealable 16 oz. tub – Keeps treats fresh and offers great value.
✅ Grain-free and no artificial additives – Cleaner ingredients than many competitors.
✅ Great for training and bonding – High reward value encourages positive behavior.
❌ Not suitable for cats with severe seafood allergies – Contains fish and shellfish derivatives.
❌ Can encourage treat dependency – Some cats may start refusing regular food if over-treated.
❌ Tub can be opened by determined cats – While resealable, clever felines may still access it unsupervised.
❌ Strong odor may bother sensitive humans – The fishy smell is potent upon opening.
❌ Not a complete nutritional supplement – Should not replace balanced meals.
Overall, the pros far outweigh the cons for the majority of cat owners. The few drawbacks are manageable with proper supervision and moderation.
What Customers Are Saying About Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight
Customer Review: “My three cats go absolutely bonkers for these! I shake the tub and it’s like a stampede. Even my picky 14-year-old who turns his nose up at everything comes running. The resealable tub is a lifesaver—keeps them fresh and stops the kittens from breaking in. Highly recommend!” – Sarah M., verified purchase
Customer Review: “I was skeptical because my cat usually ignores treats, but these changed everything. She does tricks now just to get one! Love that they’re low-calorie too—I don’t feel guilty giving them daily. Only complaint is the smell is strong, but hey, the cats don’t mind!” – David L., verified purchase
Customer Review: “Great value for the size. Lasts forever even with two hungry boys. Texture is perfect—my senior cat can eat them easily. Only wish there was a non-seafood version for my allergic kitty, but the rest of the crew loves it.” – Priya K., verified purchase
Is Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight Right for You?
Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight is ideal for:
- Multi-cat households – The variety and quantity ensure everyone gets a fair share.
- Training-focused owners – High motivation value makes behavior reinforcement easy.
- Seniors or cats with dental issues – Soft interior is gentle on teeth and gums.
- Busy pet parents – Convenient tub and long shelf life reduce shopping frequency.
You should consider skipping it if:
- Your cat has a known allergy to fish or shellfish.
- You prefer raw, freeze-dried, or entirely natural/organic treats.
- Your cat is severely overweight and requires strict calorie monitoring (consult your vet first).
Is Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight Worth the Price?
At current Amazon pricing (typically around $12–$15 for the 16 oz. tub), Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight offers exceptional value. Compared to premium single-flavor treats that cost $8–$10 for just 5 oz., this product delivers more variety, better texture, and longer-lasting supply. Even mid-tier brands struggle to match its combination of quality and affordability.
When you factor in the resealable tub, low calorie count, and universal feline appeal, the long-term value is clear. You’re not just buying treats—you’re investing in happier cats, easier training, and fewer trips to the store. For the price of a fancy coffee, you get weeks of joy for your pet.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I give these to my kitten?
A: Yes! These treats are safe for kittens over 6 months old. Just adjust portion size accordingly.
Q: How many treats should I give per day?
A: Veterinarians recommend treats should not exceed 10% of your cat’s daily caloric intake. For an average 10-lb cat, 5–8 treats daily is safe.
Q: Are these treats made in the USA?
A: Yes, Temptations products are manufactured in the United States under strict quality standards.
Q: Do they help with hairballs?
A: No, these are not formulated as hairball remedies. Look for specialized products if that’s your goal.
Q: Can dogs eat these?
A: Technically yes, but they’re not nutritionally balanced for dogs and may cause digestive upset. Keep them cat-only.
Q: Why do my cats act so crazy when I shake the tub?
A: The sound triggers their hunting instincts—it mimics the noise of prey moving, which is deeply ingrained in feline behavior.
Q: Are there other flavors available?
A: Yes! Temptations offers multiple MixUps varieties, including Chicken & Beef and Creamy Delight.
Q: How long do they stay fresh after opening?
A: Up to 6 months if stored in a cool, dry place and the tub is sealed properly.
Q: Are these treats gluten-free?
A: Yes, they contain no gluten-containing ingredients.
Q: My cat won’t eat them—what now?
A: Try warming them slightly (not microwaving) to enhance aroma, or crush them over their regular food as a topper.
Final Verdict: Should You Buy Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight?
After weeks of testing with two very different cats, I can confidently say that Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight earns its 4.8-star reputation. ★★★★☆ (4.8/5)
Key takeaways:
- It’s highly palatable and motivates even the pickiest eaters.
- The texture, flavor variety, and low calorie count make it a standout.
- The resealable tub adds convenience and freshness.
- It’s affordable, practical, and vet-approved for daily use.
If you’re looking for a treat that your cat will genuinely love—and that you’ll feel good about giving—this is one of the best options on the market. Just remember to use it wisely: moderation is key to maintaining a healthy diet.
Conclusion
In the world of cat treats, it’s rare to find a product that pleases both feline and human. Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight manages to do exactly that. From its irresistible aroma and satisfying crunch to its thoughtful packaging and nutritional balance, it checks nearly every box a pet parent could want. My cats adore it, my wallet approves, and my daily routine is smoother because of it.
Whether you’re rewarding good behavior, bonding with a new kitten, or simply treating your senior cat to something special, these treats deliver consistent results. They’re not perfect—no product is—but for the vast majority of cat owners, the benefits far outweigh the minor drawbacks.
Final recommendation: Buy the 16 oz. tub of Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight. Your cat will thank you with purrs, headbutts, and maybe even a few zoomies around the house. And honestly? That’s worth every penny.
Ready to make treat time the highlight of your cat’s day? Check current pricing on Amazon and grab a tub today!
Ready to Experience Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight?
Get the best price and verified reviews on Amazon today.